Monday, September 23, 2013

Recognition For William Mahone

Kevin M. Levin*

[Crossposted from the Civil War Memory blog]

Last week's post on the Civil War Memory blog about the unveiling of three plaques honoringVirginia’s post-Civil War black politicians has me thinking about my old buddy, William Mahone. While Mahone is best remembered as the “Hero of the Crater” his role in launching and leading the state’s most successful third-party political movement has largely been forgotten. In Virginia it was intentionally ignored because what came to be known as the Readjuster Party (1879-83) was bi-racial. The arc from Mahone’s role in preventing a Union breakthrough outside Petersburg that left scores of black Union soldiers massacred on the Crater battlefield to creating an opportunity for the largest number of black Virginians to vote, go to school and serve in positions of local and state government just a few short years later could not be more striking. Could anyone in 1865 anticipate that it would be a former Confederate general who would bring Reconstruction to Virginia?

Is it time to recognize William Mahone publicly in some shape or form? I say yes, if for no other reason than it would help to bring into sharper focus a piece of Virginia’s history that places yesterday’s dedication in its proper context. In other words, post-Civil War Virginia makes absolutely no sense without a reference to Mahone and the Readjuster Party.  It matters, not simply because it’s part of Virginia’s history, but because it has something important to teach us as well. The period following the official years of Reconstruction (1865-1877) did not inevitably lead to Jim Crow. Interracial cooperation was not only possible in the South between 1877 and the turn of the twentieth century but a reality for a few short years in Virginia. Virginia’s Reconstruction was not forced on it by “carpetbaggers” and “scalawags” but by legitimate stakeholders, who believed that a brighter future could be forged for both races. Finally, there is something juicy about all of this being introduced by a former Confederate general.

But let’s not get ahead of ourselves. Admittedly, Mahone is not the most likeable person. In fact, in all the years that I researched the man I never caught more than a fleeting glimpse of any emotional life beyond that facial here. (BTW, I still can't picture the man laughing.) We like to be able to empathize with those historical figures we recognize and commemorate. More to the point, I still don’t fully understand why Mahone decided to forge a bi-racial coalition. Was he motivated by lingering bitterness over his railroad going into receivership in the early 1870s – a turn of events that Mahone blamed on Virginia’s Conservative elements. Was Mahone simply thirsty for political power and understood that interracial cooperation offered the best chance of success? Finally, to what extent was he genuinely interested in advancing the cause of the state’s black population? I don’t know, but I suspect that it’s a combination of all three as well as other factors. Mahone was a complicated guy and his motives were not likely pure, but than again, who among our most beloved public servants could make such a claim.

I don’t know what a proper commemoration of Mahone might look like. The city of Petersburg owns Mahone’s postwar home, which now serves as a library and was interestingly enough the scene of a civil rights protest that led to its integration in the 1960s. His boyhood home in Southampton County is owned by the Sons of Confederate Veterans. Perhaps some kind of plaque could be unveiled on the capital grounds in Richmond. The form it takes doesn’t really concern me much.

What matters to me is the act of once again taking ownership of a small piece of history that we no longer have a reason to ignore.

Kevin M. Levin is an Instructor of American history at Gann Academy near Boston. He is the author of Remembering the Battle of the Crater: War as Murder (2012) and is currently writing a book on the history of Confederate camp servants and the myth of the black Confederate soldier. Levin’s essays have appeared online in The New York Times and the Atlantic as well as popular magazines and academic journals. Levin has been blogging at Civil War Memory since November 2005.


hcr said...

Mahone has always fascinated me, too. Ditto for the Readjusters.

Also fascinating is that Reconstruction politics are so completely understudied. So many of the roots of today are buried there, and yet we often seem to act as if American politics began with WWII, or even President Reagan.

Thanks for this.

Kevin Levin said...

I spend a big chunk of chapter 3 of my book on the politics of the Readjusters, but Jane Dailey's Before Jim Crow: The Politics of Race in Postemancipation Virginia (UNC Press) is the best source.

Kevin at Civil War Memory

hcr said...

There's a dissertation on them I liked, too, but it never came out in print. Still, there's much more to be done on 3rd party politics in the late 19th C., I think.

Randall said...

Are there memorials in Mississippi, Louisiana, and elsewhere in the former Confederacy to those politicians and leaders who fought for a new, more open/inclusive South? I can't recall ever seeing one.

hcr said...

Randall, I don't think there are ANY memorials to Reconstruction politicians. That's why Kevin's post about the recognition of some of them last week was so eye opening.

I don't think there are any national parks around Reconstruction either. Would love to be corrected.

I do know that there is a move in Columbia, SC to open Woodrow Wilson's family home from the 1870s as a museum. Tom Brown is in on that, so it promises to be excellent.

Kevin Levin said...

I don't believe there are any monuments to Reconstruction either, though we need to be thinking about this as we approach the end of the sesquicentennial. My hope is that the institutions that have taken the lead to commemorate the Civil War 150 will leave some room for Reconstruction. The major problem is that we don't have an NPS site that focuses specifically on Reconstruction. I recently raised this issue on the blog:

Bland Whitley said...

I'm pretty certain there are no recognitions of Reconstruction in Mississippi, the politics of which were fairly well-dominated by discussions/memories of the violent white overthrow of the Republican regime for 50 years and beyond. Oddly enough, though, there is now an historical marker in Virginia for Blanche K. Bruce, the African American Republican who represented Mississippi in the U.S. Senate from '74 to '80. But yes, there needs to be a constant drumbeat promoting Reconstruction in the historical imagination.

Bland Whitley said...

One more point, more related to the Readjusters. Mahone was not a lone wolf. The movement's leadership cadre was full of ex-Confederates: William Cameron, John Sergeant Wise, William C. Elam, and the list goes on. Many of them went on to become loyal Republicans (for a time anyway) after the parties effectively merged in 1883 or 1884. None of these guys was exactly a racial liberal, but they did need black votes. Evidence of how fluid things could/can be when voting rights were less constrained.