Saturday, December 4, 2010

Contingency: In the Event of a Moon Disaster . . .

Morgan Hubbard

When I lead discussion sections as a Teaching Assistant at UMass, I try as often as I can to bring up the notion of historical contingency. I think it’s important that we keep in mind, all of us, that the world looks and works as it does in large part because of the collected decisions of many people over many years. But history has a weight to it, and when we learn it as children and young adults it can acquire an inertia that feels like determinism: things are the way they are because they couldn’t have been any other way, right?

Every once in a while, a historical document is

especially good at shaking up this determinism.

Below is a July, 1969, memo titled 'IN EVENT OF MOON DISASTER' written by then-speechwriter William Safire to Richard Nixon's Chief of Staff, H. R. Haldeman. The memo was penned two days before the first manned moon landing. It was meant to be read by Nixon as a public statement in the event that astronauts Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin were somehow stranded on the moon during the Apollo 11 mission and consigned to perish, as the statement reads, in “the deepest of the deep.”

http://www.archives.gov/press/press-kits/american-originals-photos/moon-disaster-1.jpg

http://www.archives.gov/press/press-kits/american-originals-photos/moon-disaster-2.jpg

Images courtesy of the National Archives and hat tip to the fantastic blog Letters of Note. Click images to enlarge.

1 comment:

hcr said...

Morgan:

This is really cool. We never really think about the stuff that didn't happen. One of the commenters about the recent wikileaks dump pointed out that it shows wars averted, trouble calmed-- things that don't make the history books. This does the same thing, although with far more punch! Thanks for posting it.